- Bedrooms: 6
- Bathrooms: 8
- Parking: 2
- Size: 718.14 m²
- Price: $7,499,999
Welcome to 19 Holly St, Montauk—a newly constructed luxury residence of exceptional caliber, privately nestled within the coveted Hither Woods community and accompanied by beach access rights, including exclusive parking and gate keys to multiple private ocean beaches along Old Montauk Highway. Scheduled for completion this summer, this extraordinary coastal retreat presents a rare opportunity to acquire a newly built legacy property in one of Montauk's most prestigious and sought-after enclaves.
Graciously situated on a tranquil, tree-lined setting and spanning over 7,728 sq ft of meticulously curated living space, this 5+ bedroom, 6 full bath, 2 half bath residence—complete with dedicated office space and an exquisite library/reading room—has been masterfully designed to embody understated opulence, architectural balance, and refined coastal sophistication.
A serene palette of white oak flows seamlessly throughout the residence, establishing an atmosphere of warmth, tranquility, and timeless elegance. The thoughtful interplay of natural wood, expansive glass, and hand-selected stone creates an elevated aesthetic that feels both modern and enduring. Oversized living areas are accentuated by soaring ceilings and dramatic walls of glass, allowing natural light to flood the home effortlessly while creating an extraordinary sense of volume and airiness.
Every inch of the residence has been designed with uncompromising attention to detail. The spectacular chef's kitchen is outfitted with Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances and complemented by a beautifully appointed butler's pantry, seamlessly connecting the home's expansive entertaining spaces. Multiple indoor and outdoor living environments, two serene private courtyards, and a stunning second-story terrace create an effortless flow between luxurious living and Montauk's natural beauty.
The primary living experience is further elevated by a fully finished lower level, hydronic heating, four-zone central air conditioning, a gas fireplace, 400-amp electrical service, and an expansive attached two-car garage. The residence is also thoughtfully pre-wired for a future whole-house generator, EV charging capability, and a property-wide integrated sound system.
Curated finishes of the highest caliber define the interiors and exteriors, including premium selections of travertine and limestone, a cedar roof, custom millwork, and distinctive Newport Brass and Kohler plumbing fixtures—each element selected to create a cohesive and lasting luxury experience.
The outdoor setting rivals the interiors in beauty and execution. A spectacular, fully heated gunite pool, nearly 645 sq ft, anchors the resort-style grounds, surrounded by over 2,000 sq ft of decking, ambient landscape lighting, lush lawn landscaping, and an impressive oak pergola complete with a fully equipped outdoor kitchen, designed for elevated entertaining under the Montauk sky.
Crafted by AGC Construction—widely regarded as Montauk's most respected builder—this residence reflects a level of craftsmanship, execution, and luxury rarely brought to market.
Perhaps most compelling is the extraordinary value proposition:
The opportunity to acquire newly constructed luxury of this scale, level of finish, and pedigree at approximately $970 per square foot—an offering that is becoming increasingly rare in the Montauk market.
19 Holly St is not simply a home; it is a statement of lifestyle, design, and permanence—a generational coastal property where modern luxury and Montauk's timeless beauty exist in perfect harmony.
6 bedrooms in Montauk
- 6 Bedroom Home for Sale in Montauk - New York - USA Montauk $4,995,000
6 bedrooms in nearby cities
- 6 Bedroom Home with Two Artist Cabins for Sale in Woodstock - New York - USA Woodstock $1,325,000
- 6 Bedroom Home for Sale in Lagrangeville - New York - USA Lagrangeville $895,000
- 6 Bedroom Home for Sale in Tarrytown - New York - USA Tarrytown $2,450,000
- 6-Bedroom House for Sale in Jericho, New York, USA Jericho $1,799,800
- 6-Bedroom House for Sale in Amityville, New York, USA Amityville $699,999
- 6-Bedroom House for Sale in Fire Island Pines, Fire Island, NY Fire Island Pines $2,500,000